PLURIBUS

Share this post

George Washington University President Condemns Anti-China Artwork, Then Reverses Course

www.pluri.blog

Discover more from PLURIBUS

Providing original commentary and aggregating the best work on the illiberal impulses that threaten freedom and social cohesion.
Over 1,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in
Kowtow Chronicles

George Washington University President Condemns Anti-China Artwork, Then Reverses Course

A troubling episode of hypersensitivity and illiberal impulses at a university in the nation's capital over critiques of China.

Pluribus
Feb 8, 2022
1
Share this post

George Washington University President Condemns Anti-China Artwork, Then Reverses Course

www.pluri.blog
Share
George Washington statue at George Washington University in DC

Last week, a controversy started brewing at George Washington University in Washington, D.C. after posters appeared on campus depicting the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) human rights abuses in light of the Winter Olympic Games in Beijing:

Twitter avatar for @badiucao
巴丢草 Badiucao💉💉 @badiucao
1/ @GWtweets George Washington University Chinese Students and Scholars Association (GWUCSSA) is launching a witch-hunt to the student activists puting my boycott #beijing2022  posters in campus. A classic smear campaign to cancel criticism against CCP via calling it “racism”.
Image
Image
Image
3:44 AM ∙ Feb 5, 2022
1,530Likes669Retweets
Twitter avatar for @badiucao
巴丢草 Badiucao💉💉 @badiucao
2/ The collection posted in @GWtweets includes 5 posters depicting CCP’s 1. Oppression of the Tibetans 2. Uyghur genocide 3. The dismantling of HK democracy 4. The regime’s omnipresent surveillance systems 5. lack of transparency surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic.
Image
3:50 AM ∙ Feb 5, 2022
889Likes312Retweets

These posters generated outrage from the GWU Chinese Students and Scholars Association (GWUCSSA), calling the artwork “anti-China” and “racist” even though the artist, Badiucao, is Chinese-Australian.  

Then, on Sunday, GWU’s president issued a statement saying that he was “personally offended by the posters” and that the school was “working to have all these offensive posters removed as soon as possible.”

Twitter avatar for @badiucao
巴丢草 Badiucao💉💉 @badiucao
1. In response to CSSA, GeorgeWashington Uni @GWtweets president @PresWrightonGW claims he is “personally offended” by my art criticising China’s rights abuse like Uyghur genocide & oppression in Tibet & HongKong. I demand him an explanation why exposing CCP’s abuse offends him.
Image
Image
Image
2:00 AM ∙ Feb 7, 2022
1,931Likes708Retweets

Here’s one aspect about such maneuvers that multiple commentators are beginning to notice: the way CCP-sympathizers use the racial hypersensitivity of elite U.S. institutions against them. These posters, of course, were created by a person of Chinese descent and are targeted at a brutal regime, not a race or ethnicity. But all it took to get the president of an American university to consider censoring expression insulting to the CCP was to frame that expression as an act of racism.

As Badiucao himself put it:

Twitter avatar for @mkhammer
Mary Katharine Ham @mkhammer
I spoke with @badiucao about the complaints about his artwork today: "They [CCP] are very good at kind of using anti-racism as a way to canceling the real criticism against Chinese government. They’re always trying to mix the very idea between people, country, & gov't."
2:32 AM ∙ Feb 7, 2022
178Likes27Retweets

Fortunately, the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) swiftly responded to GWU’s illiberal instincts:

Twitter avatar for @TheFIREorg
FIRE @TheFIREorg
In response to reported efforts to identify who posted flyers depicting @badiucao's artwork at George Washington University:
Image
3:09 AM ∙ Feb 7, 2022
1,769Likes520Retweets

The next day, GWU’s president backed down, saying he “responded hastily,” adding “[u]pon full understanding, I do not view these posters as racist; they are political statements.”  

Twitter avatar for @rwocon
Rory O’Connor @rwocon
A welcome change of tune from @PresWrightonGW:
Image
Image
6:34 PM ∙ Feb 7, 2022
75Likes15Retweets

While it’s good to see GWU’s president admit his error and suspend the investigation, it’s troubling that his initial instinct was to censor artwork that was clearly making constitutionally protected political statements about widely known CCP human rights abuses. What’s worse is the implication that if the artwork wasn’t critiquing the Olympics or expressing some other approved viewpoint, the president would be okay with censorship and punishment. As FIRE put it, the president’s “belated positive opinion of the posters’ content should not determine whether students can see it.”

We’ll leave you with this:

Twitter avatar for @AGHamilton29
AG @AGHamilton29
@mkhammer “Someone complained that they were offended so we immediately issued an apology and agreed to censor the offensive material without knowing what it was” is such a perfect representation of how University administrations work these days.
6:39 PM ∙ Feb 7, 2022
179Likes39Retweets
1
Share this post

George Washington University President Condemns Anti-China Artwork, Then Reverses Course

www.pluri.blog
Share
Previous
Next
Comments
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 PLURIBUS
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing